The Cur

Content Design and Relations, OnlyFans Gigs

Fansly vs. OnlyFans: Which Platform Pays More, Grows Faster, and Wins in 2025?

Choosing between Fansly and OnlyFans? This no-fluff guide breaks down features, payouts, and growth tools so you can pick the right platform to maximize your creator income.

Fansly vs. OnlyFans

Table of Contents

1: Background: Fansly & OnlyFans

OnlyFans burst onto the scene in 2016, quickly becoming the heavyweight champion of adult content, especially during the pandemic.

Fansly launched in 2020 but surged into prominence in 2021 after OnlyFans flirted with an adult content ban. Although OnlyFans swiftly backtracked, Fansly had already cemented itself as a formidable rival.

Today, both platforms are top picks for creators, each with its own vibe.

2: Key Differences Between Fansly & OnlyFans

Audience and Reach

OnlyFans: Boasts over 190 million registered users and 3 million creators, offering instant credibility thanks to its massive, loyal following. However, the competition is fierce.

Fansly: With 130 million active users and over 2 million creators, it's less saturated. This means quicker visibility if you nail your niche, though you might have to work a little harder to convert new users.

Go for OnlyFans if you have a pre-established network or agency and monetary resources to deploy in hiring your own support team. If you're starting out and are confident in the niche you are targeting, Fansly might be a better choice.

Monetization Options

Both platforms let you charge monthly subscriptions, send paid messages, and collect tips. However:

  • OnlyFans: Subscription prices range from $4.99 to $49.99 (single tier only) and offers additional merch sales opportunities.
  • Fansly: Allows a broader pricing range, from $4.99 up to an eye-popping $499.99, supports multiple subscription tiers, and permits higher single-tip limits ($500 vs. $200).

The ability to create multiple tiers may allow creators to structure content even better in Fansly. However, the presence of merch sales opportunities in OnlyFans would appeal more to the experienced creators.

Income Potential

Your earnings depend on subscriber count, pricing, and upselling tactics like custom content and tips.

Top creators on OnlyFans can hit six or even seven figures annually (though only about 10% reach that elite level), with newcomers typically earning between $180 and $500 per month.

On Fansly, creators usually earn between $180 and $250 monthly, with a few big names claiming $5,000 to $7,000 in peak months. Lower tip minimums on Fansly can drive more frequent transactions, even if the overall earnings start lower.

Payouts & Fees

Both platforms operate on an 80/20 revenue split (you keep 80%, platform takes 20%).

OnlyFans: Uses a 7-day holding period (21 days initially in some regions) with payouts typically arriving within 3–5 business days. Payment methods include bank transfers, e-wallets, Venmo, and Paxum.

Fansly: Also features a 7-day holding period but is known for lightning-fast withdrawals (usually 1–2 business days) and supports Skrill, Paxum, cryptocurrency, and bank transfers with varying minimum thresholds.

Platform Features

OnlyFans: Lets you schedule posts to keep your content flowing without needing to be online 24/7. It also offers advanced analytics, fan categorization, and interactive tools like polls and quizzes.

Fansly: Stands out with a built-in search feature that boosts discoverability, a “For You” page for trending content, and multi-tier subscriptions that allow you to diversify your income.

OnlyFans has been around for longer and is more technically equipped to handle better content delivery facilities as compared to Fansly. There is nothing in Fansly that is not available in OnlyFans already.

User Experience & Support

OnlyFans: While its massive user base is a plus, its browsing experience can be clunky. The UI has been criticised quite a few times. Customer support can be inconsistent, with response times stretching up to a week.

Fansly: Boasts a cleaner, more intuitive interface. Their customer support tends to be more responsive, though the FAQ section might need a bit more clarity.

Security & Privacy

Both platforms protect your content with automatic watermarks and geoblocking tools, making it tough for anyone to steal your work. These features ensure your content remains secure and help you prove ownership if disputes arise.

3: Which Platform Reigns Supreme?

A Reddit survey revealed that 33.8% of creators prefer Fansly, while 22.9% favor OnlyFans. Many savvy creators actually use both: leveraging OnlyFans’ vast reach as their main hub and Fansly as a strategic backup.

If you're after a larger, more established audience and higher earning potential, OnlyFans might be your go-to. But if you value a less crowded space, advanced subscription options, and a slicker interface, Fansly could be your secret weapon.

4: Final Verdict

The best platform ultimately depends on your niche, marketing savvy, and long-term goals. Experiment, engage, and consider leveraging both to maximize your creator income in 2025 and beyond!

The best option is always to diversify. Which platform you focus on would depend on your ambitions, but utilizing both channels can not only prevent platform lock-ins but also more engagement tactics.

How Can We Help?

Whether you decide to go for Fansly or OnlyFans, every content creator would require support in building their content teams: managers, chatters, specialists, etc. Same follows for agencies looking to expand their roster.

That's where we come in - a platform where you can hire such resources. We cherry-pick qualified individuals who have experience in this field and connect them to you for a small one-time fee. Check out our candidate database offerings for more details.

Want to post a job ad? We've got you covered! Explore a plan to suit your needs that comes with built-in analytics to see how many people are looking at your job listing. And check out our existing listings here.